Property deals may sometimes be abandoned halfway after certain payments like token money have been made. The deal may be cancelled by either the seller or the buyer for a variety of reason. This can trigger in number of questions in the mind of buyers.
Will the seller refund my money?
If so, will he refund all the money or would he make some deductions?
What should I do if, the seller refuses to refund the advance money?
Am I legally obliged to let go of the token amount?
We try to answer all of these questions in this article.
What happens after a property deal is cancelled?
Even if a deal falls through, this is no reason for buyers to lose heart since the seller will be responsible to refund the money they might have taken from you as the token money as along as he is responsible for the deal getting cancelled. For this reason, the terms and conditions about refund must be clearly stated in the initial agreement to sell so that no confusion remains on the subject of refund, if a deal were to fall through.
See also: Token money refund rules for a property purchase
How is token money taxed?
In case of deals for the purchase of any real estate, the buyer generally pays some amount as token money when the other terms and conditions for the transfer of the property are agreed upon. The amount of token money may vary from being merely a token to a substantial percentage of the value of the property. If the seller backs off from his commitment to sell his property, there are no immediate financial implications, except that the buyer gets a right to file a suit for specific performance in the courts of law. However, this is generally not the case.
If the buyer backs out from the deal, the seller has the right to forfeit the token money paid. With respect to such forfeited token money, the buyer cannot claim any income tax benefit, as this is treated as a capital loss under the tax laws. However, the advance money/earnest money that is forfeited becomes an income of the seller in the year in which the deal is called off. Such forfeited earnest money is taxed under the head ‘income from other sources’ and not under the head ‘capital gains’, even though the income is received with respect to a capital asset. Before the amendment of the law in 2014, the amount of forfeited earnest money was required to be deducted from the cost of acquisition of the asset with respect to which it was received, in the year in which the asset, which is the subject matter of the deal, was sold.
See also: How to calculate stamp duty?
Refund of stamp duty
Generally, for all property transactions, the buyer has to pay certain amount as stamp duty. This is either a fixed amount or a percentage of the property’s market value. You also have to pay registration charges, for registration of the agreement. The stamp duty rates and registration charges payable, are determined by the respective state governments. So, the rules for refund of stamp duty that is paid for property transactions, would vary from state to state. You are required to pay the stamp duty before the execution of the document.
In Maharashtra, you are entitled to claim refund of the stamp duty, within 6 months from its payment in certain situations. You can claim the refund of stamp duty paid on such instrument if the same has not been executed. The government deducts 1% of the stamp duty, subject to a minimum of Rs 200 and a maximum of Rs 1,000 of the stamp duty paid.
In case of cancellation of a deal for the purchase of a property and for which the agreements have already been registered, the Maharashtra government allows a longer period of two years from the date of the agreement, for claiming the refund of the stamp duty, subject to certain conditions. This refund is allowed, only if the developer fails to hand over possession of the property booked and this fact, as the reason for cancellation of the deal, is mentioned in the cancellation deed. The rules also provide that the cancellation agreement should be registered.
The buyer of the property can get a refund of 98% of the stamp duty if an application is made for a refund of the stamp duty. With the refund application, you are required to attach the original agreement, as well as the original cancellation deed, with both the documents being registered. However, you will not get a refund of the registration charges.
Refund of GST (Goods and Services Tax)
When you book an under-construction property, as per the existing laws, the developer levies a GST on the agreement value at a certain rate. This rate will depend on whether the property falls under the ‘affordable housing’ category or not and also on whether the developer is availing of the input credit. For any reason, if you want to cancel the booking and thus, surrender your rights over the under-construction property, the builder may agree to refund the booking amount and instalments paid, or even agree to pay a higher amount to you, depending on the demand and supply dynamics at that time. Although the developer may have collected GST from you, he may or may not agree to refund this amount, as he may have already deposited the amount to the credit of the government. The builder will not be entitled to claim any refund with respect to the GST, as he has already rendered services to you.
In case you enter into an agreement to transfer your rights in the under-construction property to a third party, with the developer being the confirming party, your sale price would be inclusive of the GST and you will not be able to separately recover or charge any GST on such transaction. While computing the capital gains, the GST that is already paid by you, will form part of the cost of acquisition. The capital gains will be taxable as long-term, if your holding period has been three years, or else, the profits, if any realised, will be taxed as short-term capital gains.
See also: Partnership deed must be stamped as required by Indian Stamps Act
Word of caution
As it is possible that the property deal may not move in the direction you intended it to, buyers must keep in mind certain points, to safeguard their interests. The first step in that direction, is to avoid paying any money in cash. If money is paid in cash, the seller might later refuse to return the money, if there is no legal proof that you made the payment.
Also, every effort should be made to avoid any dispute during the process. While buyers have several legal recourse available to seek relief, the process to claim that relief is often long drawn and monetarily expensive. In your best interest, sit across the table and discuss the matter with the other party. They too, surely, do not want to be dragged to the courts, which would result in them losing time and money.
Unless you have been dealing with an absolutely honest party, you run the risk of losing time, money and energy, if you depend solely on verbal commitments, without giving this commitment a legal form by way of documentation. This is why buyers must always insist on getting everything in written at every juncture of the transaction.
See also: Dos and don’ts for paying token money for a property purchase
Is Stamp Duty refundable on cancellation of flat?
The buyer of the property can get a refund of 98% of the stamp duty, if an application is made for a refund of the stamp duty. With the refund application, you are required to attach the original agreement, as well as the original cancellation deed, with both the documents being registered. However, you will not get a refund of the registration charges.
Is GST refundable on cancellation of flat?
Although the developer may have collected GST from you, he may or may not agree to refund this amount, as he may have already deposited the amount to the credit of the government.
Is token money received taxable for the seller?
The advance money/earnest money that is forfeited, becomes an income of the seller in the year in which the deal is called off. Such forfeited earnest money is taxed under the head ‘income from other sources’ and not under the head ‘capital gains’, even though the income is received with respect to a capital asset.
(Balwant Jain is a tax and investment expert, with 35 years’ experience)